I feel the need to grace this latest trip with some context. It looks like it will be the trip that sees me out of the EU whilst in the E!
Article 50 is done, the Queen has given her ‘approval’; the Withdrawal years have started. Mr Johnson has promised it will all be done and dusted by the end of the year (the end of 2020). But what, exactly, will this mean? Will we have everything signed sealed and delivered? Will there be a reaction from our European chums? Will I be allowed back into the UK?
I seem to have spent the entirety (20k+ words so far) of the last eleven months asking stupid questions. I’m still not sure why we wanted out of the EU. I’ve talked to quite a few reasonable people and they all have their frustrations, but no one can tell me why leaving a club full of friends with benefits will make my life any better.
I understand that it may go deeper than the economic arguments, or a nostalgia for the ‘good old days’, it may be more about identity and patriotism, or distrust of foreigners. Brexit may just be a terrible mistake. We’ve made mistakes before.
Europe had a turbulent time of it in the twentieth century. After centuries of belligerence; as one empire replaced another; as religious differences turned the continent upside down; as technological innovations and new ideas about human nature swept aside ancient ways of doing things. We stumbled from one conflict to the next.
Was the 1st World War a mistake? Winston Churchill suggested that Keiser Wilhelm II started the conflagration by mistake – when he threw his cigarette down and went sailing in his big yacht, only to find on his return, ‘… the building impenetrable with smoke.’
I still can’t find a definitive cause for The Great War (1914-1918) that forced my grand father to fight people he had no argument with. The second world war (1939-1945), which took my father to the far east seems a bit more black-and-white; if one sees it as a straightforward fight against fascism (but, of course, it was anything but a straight shot out between good and evil). And, on this 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz (27th January 1945), I will never understand how people could do the things they did in that place.
Much has been written about Auschwitz and the Holocaust. Was this also a mistake; a horror created out of a confluence of resentment (fed by the consequences of WWI), of ignorance and a search for identity (stoked by propaganda designed to prove an international Jewish conspiracy), an inevitable by-product of what the historian Peter Hall described as ‘the world’s first modern military-industrial state’, the blind actions of a new country whose citizens were famously disciplined and obedient. The Dutch writer Geert Mak (in his wonderful book, In Europe: travels through the twentieth century) suggests that, ‘The roots of … anti-Semitism ran deep’. But he goes on to develop a deeper, more complicated, argument that reflects financial gain, conflicts between neighbours, an absence of a ‘mentality of resistance’, bureaucratic excess and technocrat zeal.
Could we be making a terrible mistake again. The consequences of which will only be apparent to the historians of the future; many of them probably currently benefiting from a sound university education and a place on the Erasmus program? One thing is for certain – I need to do more research, talk to more Europeans, and visit more EU member states.
*Sorry about the terrible pun – Jacques Delors (President of the European Commission 1985-1995) will be spinning!
by